Sorry but i have to call bullshit on that.
It was never meant to be a complete sim, it saids in the description it is meant to be a successor of ''Red Storm Rising''.
It plays nearly the same.
Then again, different tastes, i get it, but calling a game ''poop'' simply based on the argument of ''Hur durr it's not what i thought it was D: D: D:'' is not really fair considering the game never described itself like, i say again, a full simulation.
First I didn't call it Poop neither did I say it should have been a full sim. Things I observed from some streams. Harpoon is launched and of course there is a visible eruption of water at that point. Missle hits it's target and another ship fires back at the sub. That eruption of water stayed up in the air visible for nearly the whole engagement. I begin to question the physics here.
There were other items but not so obviously a bug, such as a sub surfacing on its own. I can't say that was user error but it happened a couple of times.
If I want a sub sim I'd play Silent Service or something else. But I said I am going to wait and see at this point. If it goes on sale then yeah I'll probably pick it up.